Patent and Engineering Law

With Joe Barich

Home     Engineering Law     Patent Prosecution     Patent Clinic     Barich Award     About Me     Published Articles     Presentations      




Thank You To LenzenIP

A hearty thank you to Nick Lenzen of LenzenIP for donating patent drawing drafting services for the eight patent applications drafted in the Patent Clinic!


About the Patent Clinic

The Patent Clinic was established at the University of Illinois College of Law in the spring of 2008 by Professor Barich in cooperation with the Technology Entrepreneur Center (TEC) at the University of Illinois College of Engineering. The prerequisite to participating in the Patent Clinic is completion of my Patent Prosecution class, where students learn the practical skills for drafting a patent application.  In Patent Prosecution, all students draft a patent application relating to a single new innovation conceived by me.

Conversely, in the Patent Clinic, each law student has the opportunity to put their skills to practice by writing an individual patent application (under my supervision) for an undergraduate or graduate student invention.  However, due to the fast pace and high level of competence required, participation in the Patent Clinic is only recommended for students who earned at least a B+ in Patent Prosecution.  The Patent Clinic is currently only offered in the spring semester.

Most recently (spring 2010) we had eight law students participate.  We worked with the Technology Entrepreneur Center (TEC) and with participants in the Lemelson Innovation Competition and Cozad New Venture Competition.  From the dozens of innovations that were considered, eight were selected (one per law student) and each law student wrote a full patent application with regard to their chosen innovation.  The patent applications were then provided to the inventors (although the inventors must resolve their rights with the Office of Technology Management before filing the patent application.)

In our inaugural year (2008) we had six law students participate and we drafted six full patent applications toward six innovations in cooperation with the TEC's Lemelson and Cozad Competitions.  In our second year (2009), we had seven law students participate and we drafted seven full patent applications.

Next year and we look forward to an even more successful semester hopefully with even more law student and inventor participation.

2010 Patent Clinic Intro Presentation -
Presented Friday, January 22, 2010


2010 Patent Clinic Participation Agreement

2010 Patent Clinic Closing Presentation -
Presented Friday, April 30, 2010


2010 Patent Clinic Closing Presentation Handouts


2010 Innovations

Patent applications drafted in 2010 concerned:
  • Low-cost, single-use blood panels and affordable automated analysis devices that will provide diagnostic solutions for developing countries.
  • A screen impregnated with silver nanoparticles that keeps water fresh and enhances the shelf-life of milk at ambient temperatures for people in developing countries.
  • An apparatus that aids in decision making and learning using haptic qualities that allow the user to engage in the thinking process by permitting them to manipulate tactile components.
  • A no-VOC whiteboard paint that allows the user to paint any surface to then use it as a white board with standard dry erase markers.
  • A new type of display that can improve the brightness, grayscale/color depth, response and simplicity of display technologies.
  • A new wheelchair with a disc brake braking system and a hill assist function to help users travel uphill without rolling backwards.
  • A low-cost, multi-sensor, liquid level system that can easily be used in industrial settings as well as field deployments such as monitoring precipitation, sea levels, wave heights, and groundwater levels in wells. 
  • A fully-integrated, passive microfluidic logic device.

2009 Innovations

Patent applications drafted in 2009 concerned:
  • A video-related e-commerce system
  • An improved solar-based water purifier
  • A holography system
  • A roof-based hydroponic system
  • Improved materials for sporting equipment
  • An e-commerce site for fashion management
  • An internet security system


2008 Innovations

 Congratulations to Pat Walsh!
On having his innovation named as #5 on Discover Magazine's List of 10 Everyday Technologies That Can Change The World!

Pat's solar charged light product for use in impoverished rural India was one of the six innovations that we wrote a patent application for during the 2008 Patent Clinic.  Pat is currently marketing his product through his company Greenlight Planet.  We wish Pat continued tremendous success!

The other patent applications drafted in 2008 concerned:
  • Access assistance for quadriplegics
  • An identification system for cancerous cells
  • A lifesaving traffic safety device
  • A microfluidic analysis laboratory tool
  • A computer processing management system

Comments From Law Students Participating in the Patent Clinic
  • [2010] Professor Barich was interested in student learning and very accessible both in class and out of class
  • [2010] Appreciated sharing updates in law and regulations concerning patent prosecution.
  • [2010] Prof. Barich is a great asset for us.  I like the website joebarich.com.  We appreciate all the time and effort he puts in.  It has improved my career prospects greatly.
  • [2010] I appreciate having real-world experience interacting with an inventor before entering patent practice.
  • [2010] Joe knows patent law inside-and-out, always willing to explain the law in-depth.  I gained great practical experience in patent law which prepared me even better for the outside world.
  • [2010] Good practical class to further develop skills in patent prosecution.  Learning how to proceed through the process with a real world inventor was very beneficial.
  • [2010] Major strength of the professor is his practical experience that he imparts to his students.  Working with the inventor and developing my own style in interacting with him and setting deadlines was very beneficial.
  • Thanks for your dedication to teaching patent prosecution at the COL. I feel I have a good foundation for my career thanks your classes. I want to leave you with some feedback that you can share with the administration or put on your website if you'd like.  The Patent Clinic is a great asset to the COL and the university at large.  The COL may never be the #1 law school in the country, or even Illinois, but I think it has the potential to have the best Patent Clinic in the country, if it doesn't already.  I hope the administration takes advantage of this great opportunity to further boost the COL's reputation.  For my part, I look forward to telling my superiors at my New York firm about the Patent Clinic at the COL. 
  • The clinic allowed me to develop my own style when interacting with an inventor.  I set deadlines, I conducted interviews, I followed up with emails.  Prof. Barich was there to provide guidance, but I felt primarily responsible; that was why it was such an outstanding learning experience.
  • I must say that the Patent Clinic was a lot of fun. It was fantastic interacting with my grateful inventor and meeting weekly in an informal setting with awesome people. I thoroughly enjoyed it. Thanks a ton!
  • I'm sure all share these sentiments - you are a significant asset to the law program here at the U.  I look forward to hearing about the future development of the Patent Clinic. Thanks again. 
  • Just wanted to thank you for running this program. I enjoyed the experience.
  • Thanks again for providing us with such a great experience with the Patent Clinic and a great set of classes with both this and patent prosecution.
  • Thanks again for everything, Joe! The Patent Clinic was a great experience. 
  • Hey, also, I just wanted to say that I really appreciate everything you've done for us these last two years. I think it is really generous of you to spend so much of your time driving down to Champaign to invest in us. You truly are a tremendous asset to this school and its students and I hope that the administration here realizes this. In any case, I just wanted to say that I appreciate all that I've been able to learn from you. Thanks for everything.


Comments from Inventors Participating in the Patent Clinic
  • I would like to say thank you to both you and the students that made the clinic possible. It's hard to believe that there are amazing programs such as the patent clinic on campus. Without the program there is no way that a young student start-up, such as ours, could possibly have gotten together a patent application without the help of the patent clinic. Being able to say to investors that we have worked with your program and are intending to file a patent has been a tremendous asset recently, and will continue to be as we mature as a company.
  • I would also like to say that the quality of work produced by the law students was amazing and that the particular student that we worked with was very professional and knowledgeable. My partner and I were both blown away by the final product.
  • I've looked through the final patent application and am extremely happy with it!  [Law Student's] ability to organize my scatterbrained descriptions into a thorough and strong application has been remarkable. I very much appreciate his work and this Patent Clinic program in general -- this has been an invaluable service.
  • The patent application looks great! It has been a pleasure working with [Law Student] and indirectly working with you.  Thanks much for your time and I appreciate being granted this opportunity!
  • [Law Student] has done an absolutely outstanding job on this project
  • I wanted to thank you for the program and am satisfied/approve the patent application prepared by [Law Student].   [Law Student] has been extremely knowledgeable and I appreciate that you had me work with him.
  • I commend the level of detail and [Law Student's] ability to translate the complicated information I gave him into a cohesive document.  Thanks to both of you for your individual parts in this experience.
  • I will keep in touch and keep you posted with regard to my entrepreneurial effort.  It was a pleasure working with [Law Student] and you. Thanks for the opportunity.
  • woot!